Sarasota, FL — A deadly shooting that occurred Tuesday afternoon at a residence in the Amberlea subdivision of eastern Sarasota County, Florida, has left five individuals dead and shocked the local community. Preliminary information suggests that the victims are believed to be members of a family that owns and operates the Osprey Polyclinic, a well‑known Sarasota‑area medical practice. Among the victims confirmed by sources are Florita Stolyar and Tony Ioffe, both of whom were part of the Osprey Polyclinic family, though officials have not yet released the identities of the victims as authorities await next‑of‑kin notifications.
The shooting, which occurred around 12:24 p.m. on February 10, 2026, has prompted a significant response from law enforcement, including the Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office, which arrived on the scene within minutes of receiving a 911 call from a nearby resident. Deputies quickly secured the area, and it was confirmed that no survivors were found inside the home.
The case is still under investigation, and authorities have not confirmed a suspect or made any arrests. Investigators have, however, indicated that they do not believe there are any additional suspects at large and that all involved individuals have been accounted for. While the investigation continues, officials have assured the public that they are taking all necessary measures to gather facts and provide answers in this tragic and unsettling case.
The Tragic Incident: What We Know So Far
The shooting took place at a residence located at 4822 Fall Crest Circle, a private home situated near the intersection of Proctor Road and McIntosh Road in Sarasota, Florida. According to the Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office, the department received a 911 call at 12:24 p.m. from a neighboring resident who reported hearing gunshots and a possible violent situation at the home. Law enforcement officers arrived within minutes, finding the residence locked down and no immediate signs of forced entry.
Once on the scene, multiple deputies and patrol vehicles were deployed to secure the area, and access to the gated Amberlea subdivision was restricted as officers ensured that residents were properly identified before being allowed to enter the community. The situation led to a temporary closure of Proctor Road, which runs through the neighborhood, from McIntosh Road to Honore Avenue, in response to the heavy police presence.
Authorities confirmed that the shooting resulted in the deaths of five individuals, with Florita Stolyar and Tony Ioffe being among the victims, both identified by family members and sources close to the Osprey Polyclinic. However, law enforcement officials are still working to confirm the identities of the other three victims, whose personal details have not yet been publicly released.
The Response: Specialized Units and Tactical Teams Deployed
The Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office deployed a variety of specialized units to handle the shooting investigation, including:
-
Crime Scene Investigations Unit — to collect forensic evidence from the scene.
-
Forensics Team — to analyze ballistic and other physical evidence, including weapons.
-
Criminal Investigations Division — to conduct interviews with witnesses, neighbors, and anyone who might have relevant information.
-
Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) — used to conduct aerial searches for evidence or signs that may have been overlooked on the ground.
As investigators began their preliminary work, a staging area was set up at Bee Ridge Presbyterian Church at Harris and Proctor roads, a nearby location where the public and media could gather for updates. The staging area allowed officials to manage the flow of information and provide updates on the investigation as new details emerged.
The Sheriff’s Office spokesperson confirmed that one weapon was recovered at the scene, though it was not immediately clear whether this firearm was used in the shooting or if others were involved. Investigators are exploring all possibilities, including the likelihood that the shooting stemmed from a personal conflict or family dispute.
A Community in Shock: The Osprey Polyclinic Connection
At the heart of this tragedy is the Osprey Polyclinic, a well‑respected Sarasota medical practice operated by members of the Stolyar and Ioffe families. Florita Stolyar and Tony Ioffe were known to many in the community for their work in the medical field. As news of their deaths broke, both colleagues and patients expressed their shock and sorrow, many taking to social media to offer tributes and condolences.
The Stolyar and Ioffe families have worked tirelessly over the years to provide top‑quality care to patients in Sarasota and surrounding areas, and their untimely deaths have left the local healthcare community in mourning. It is unclear whether the other victims were family members, close associates, or staff members connected to the medical practice.
As law enforcement investigates, several neighbors have expressed their disbelief over the incident, noting that violent occurrences of this magnitude are extremely rare in their normally quiet, family‑oriented neighborhood. One neighbor, visibly shaken, shared that they had known the family for years and described them as “good people” who were always willing to lend a hand to others.
“It’s just unimaginable,” said one neighbor. “They’ve lived here for years, and to hear something like this happening so close to home is beyond words. My heart goes out to everyone who’s been affected by this.”
Another local resident recalled that they had often seen Florita and Tony at the local grocery store or out walking their dog, adding to the sense of community shock over the tragedy.
Initial Investigative Findings: Domestic Dispute or Targeted Attack?
While authorities have confirmed that no immediate signs of forced entry into the home were discovered, the exact circumstances leading to the shooting remain unclear. Investigators are still piecing together the facts and interviewing potential witnesses to understand the full sequence of events. One theory that has been suggested is that the shooting may have been related to a domestic dispute involving those who were killed. However, no official motive has been confirmed.
According to law enforcement sources, the home had previously been the subject of two prior law enforcement calls. However, the residence was not considered suspicious at the time, and those calls were deemed unrelated to any ongoing concerns. Despite this, investigators are not ruling out the possibility that some long‑standing family conflict or personal dispute may have escalated into the violence witnessed on February 10, 2026.
As part of their investigation, authorities are focusing on:
-
Domestic connections among the victims — Are the victims related by blood or marriage?
-
Personal disputes — Is there any history of conflict or tension within the family or among associates?
-
Forensic evidence — Was the recovered weapon linked to the shooting, and does it provide clues to the identity of the shooter?
Detectives are currently reviewing potential surveillance footage from residential security and doorbell cameras in the area, hoping to establish a timeline of events and determine what led to the violent incident. However, no clear visual evidence has yet been released to the public.
Neighbors and Community Reactions
The residents of the Amberlea subdivision, including many who live near the Stolyar and Ioffe family, have expressed a profound sense of disbelief. This residential community is known for its quiet streets and family‑oriented atmosphere, and for something as horrific as a mass shooting to occur in such an area has left many in the neighborhood in a state of shock.
Several residents spoke to the media, offering their condolences to the families affected. One neighbor, who had lived on the same street for over 15 years, said that the shooting “shattered the peaceful nature of this neighborhood.”
“I never imagined something like this could happen here,” the neighbor said. “It’s a safe community. We all know each other, and this is a complete shock. My heart goes out to everyone who’s been affected.”
The impact of the shooting extends beyond the immediate family of the victims. The Osprey Polyclinic is a well‑known name in the community, and many patients who have been treated by Florita Stolyar and Tony Ioffe are now struggling to process the loss. Several have taken to social media to express their disbelief and share fond memories of the care they received from the couple over the years.
Law Enforcement’s Efforts Moving Forward
The Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office has stated that the investigation remains ongoing, with detectives working tirelessly to gather additional evidence, conduct interviews, and piece together the events that led to the fatal shooting. They have also confirmed that the situation remains isolated, with no indication that there is any immediate threat to the broader Sarasota community.
Specialized law enforcement teams, including Crime Scene Investigations, Forensics, and Criminal Investigations, continue to work together to analyze the evidence and develop leads. Meanwhile, patrol units have been deployed throughout the area to ensure continued public safety, while unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) are being used to conduct aerial searches for any overlooked evidence.
Moving Forward: Support and Memorials for the Families
As the investigation continues, the Amberlea subdivision and Sarasota community will undoubtedly continue to support the victims’ families and loved ones. Memorial services are expected to be held in the coming days, and the community is likely to come together for a candlelight vigil or other memorials to honor the lives of Florita Stolyar, Tony Ioffe, and the other victims.
Law enforcement has called for patience as they work through the case, ensuring that the proper investigative steps are taken to identify the person or persons responsible for this deadly act. Authorities are also urging anyone with information about the shooting to come forward and assist the investigation.
Conclusion: A Grieving Community, an Ongoing Investigation
The tragic loss of five lives in a peaceful Sarasota neighborhood has left a community grieving and searching for answers. As investigators continue to piece together the facts surrounding the shooting at Fall Crest Circle, the Amberlea subdivision remains in a state of shock and disbelief. The victims — Florita Stolyar and Tony Ioffe, along with the other family members involved — will be remembered for their contributions to the local community and their commitment to improving the lives of others through their medical practice.
As the investigation moves forward, Sarasota County law enforcement agencies continue to work diligently to uncover the truth behind this horrific event, ensuring that justice is served and that the families and residents affected receive the support they need during this incredibly difficult time.
Leave a Reply