WAGONER COUNTY, Okla. — A gruesome discovery on a quiet porch in the Whitehorn Cove area has launched a major criminal investigation and left a family grieving the loss of a young mother. The Wagoner County Sheriff’s Office is investigating the suspicious death of Cheyann Paige Anderson, a 23-year-old woman found dead outside her home early last Thursday morning.

The investigation has already led to the arrests of two individuals—identified as Anderson’s roommates—who are accused of subjecting the victim to a brutal assault involving a wooden bat and a taser prior to her death. Christopher Zwirtz and Roberta Slagle are currently behind bars in the Wagoner County Jail, facing assault charges as authorities await critical autopsy results that could upgrade the case to a homicide.

For the community of Wagoner and the family of Cheyann Anderson, the details emerging from the investigation paint a disturbing picture of violence and betrayal within the walls of a shared home.

The 911 Call: A Grim Discovery in Whitehorn Cove

The timeline of the tragedy began in the early morning hours of Thursday, January 29, 2026. Deputies with the Wagoner County Sheriff’s Office were dispatched to a residence in the Whitehorn Cove area, a community located near Wagoner Lake. The initial call to 911 reported an “unconscious female.”

When deputies arrived at the scene, the reality was far worse than a medical emergency. They located Cheyann Anderson lying on her own front porch. She was not merely unconscious; she was deceased. According to investigators, her body was covered in “severe injuries,” immediately signaling to first responders that this was not a natural death.

Sheriff Chris Elliott, who is leading the investigation, described the scene as tragic. “This is the thing, she was only 23 years old and for her to die like she did, it is just very very tragic,” Elliott told reporters.

The location of the body on the porch raises harrowing questions about her final moments. Was she trying to escape? Was she placed there? These are questions detectives are working to answer as they process the scene.

The Investigation: Evidence of a Brutal Assault

Once the scene was secured, investigators executed a search warrant on the residence. The evidence found inside the home contradicted any notion of an accident.

Weapons Recovered:

• Wooden Bat: Deputies found evidence suggesting that a wooden bat had been used to beat Anderson. The nature of her injuries matched the blunt force trauma consistent with such a weapon.

• Taser: In a chilling admission, suspect Roberta Slagle reportedly told investigators that she had tased Anderson several times during an altercation.

Sheriff Elliott was blunt in his assessment of the evidence. “The evidence inside Anderson’s house clearly shows Anderson was beaten and even tased before she died,” Elliott stated.

Waiting on the Medical Examiner: While the physical evidence of assault is overwhelming, the legal path to a murder charge hinges on the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner.

• Cause of Death: Pathologists must determine if the beating and tasing were the direct cause of death, or if another factor (such as an underlying medical condition or substance) contributed.

• Homicide Potential: “We may find out she died of something else, but with the amount of damage she had on her body, we feel strongly she died of a homicide,” Sheriff Elliott explained.

If the autopsy confirms that the injuries inflicted by the roommates caused her death, the charges against Zwirtz and Slagle are expected to be upgraded immediately to First-Degree Murder or Manslaughter.

The Suspects: Roommates Behind Bars

The two individuals arrested in connection with the case were not strangers to the victim; they were people she lived with.

1. Christopher Zwirtz: Currently booked into the Wagoner County Jail on assault charges.

2. Roberta Slagle: Also booked into the Wagoner County Jail on assault charges.

The “Evil” Within: Cheyann’s grandmother, speaking to reporters, expressed the family’s heartbreak and anger. She described Cheyann as a happy person from a great family who, unfortunately, had “evil people living with her.”

The dynamic of the household is now a central focus of the investigation. Detectives are interviewing neighbors and associates to understand the relationship between Anderson and her roommates. What led to the altercation? Was there a history of domestic violence in the home? The admission of tasing suggests a level of control and cruelty that goes beyond a spur-of-the-moment fight.

Obituary: Remembering Cheyann Paige Anderson

Beyond the crime scene tape and the mugshots, there is the life of Cheyann Paige Anderson (Courtney). Born on June 12, 2002, in St. Mary’s, Maryland, Cheyann was just 23 years old when her life was taken.

A Life of Joy and Service: According to a tribute released by her mother, Cheyann spent her formative years in Florida, attending school there until the end of 11th grade before graduating from Porter High School in Oklahoma. She was a familiar face to many in the community through her work at McDonald’s, where she served as a cashier and server. Her family notes that she found “genuine joy in helping others and serving the public.” To Cheyann, a job was not just a paycheck; it was an opportunity to show kindness.

An Adventurous Spirit: Cheyann was a young woman who thrived outdoors. She found peace in nature and had a deep love for animals.

• Hobbies: Her adventurous spirit was reflected in her hobbies, which included horseback riding, hunting, and fishing. Whether she was in a saddle or by the water, the outdoors was her sanctuary.

A Loving Mother: Above all, Cheyann’s identity was defined by motherhood. She was the mother of a two-year-old little girl. “She was the loving mother of her daughter, who was the light of her life and her greatest blessing,” her mother wrote. The tragedy is compounded by the fact that a two-year-old child is now left without her mother. The family is rallying around the child, ensuring she is cared for as they navigate this nightmare.

“Cheyann will be remembered for her kind heart, her love for her family, and the joy she found in life’s simple moments,” the obituary concluded.

Sheriff’s Office Vows Justice

The Wagoner County Sheriff’s Office is treating this case with the highest priority. Sheriff Elliott has been transparent about the brutality of the crime while managing the procedural necessity of waiting for the medical examiner.

“She was only 23 years old,” Elliott repeated, underscoring the senselessness of the loss.

The Sheriff’s investigators are working to ensure that the case against Zwirtz and Slagle is airtight. By booking them on assault charges now, they ensure the suspects remain in custody while the forensic pathology work is completed. This strategy prevents flight risk and keeps the community safe.

Community Reaction

The Whitehorn Cove area is a community known for its proximity to recreation and lake life. The news of such a violent death has shaken residents. “You don’t expect to hear about people being beaten with bats and tased next door,” said a resident who wished to remain anonymous. “It makes you wonder what was going on in that house that nobody knew about.”

Social media tributes have poured in for Cheyann, with friends sharing photos of her smiling, often outdoors or with her daughter. The contrast between the happy young woman in the photos and the grim details of her death is stark.

Legal Next Steps

As the investigation enters its second week, the focus remains on the Medical Examiner’s Office in Tulsa.

1. Autopsy Report: Once the cause of death is officially ruled a homicide, the District Attorney will likely file amended charges.

2. Arraignment: Zwirtz and Slagle will face a judge for the assault charges, but legal analysts predict high bonds given the suspicious nature of the death.

3. Child Custody: Child Protective Services (DHS) is likely involved to formally place Cheyann’s two-year-old daughter with next of kin, ensuring she is safe from the environment where her mother was killed.

Conclusion: A Family Waits for Answers

Cheyann Anderson passed away on January 29, 2026, in Wagoner, Oklahoma. She leaves behind a grieving mother, a grandmother, a young daughter, and a community demanding justice.

The investigation into her death has revealed a dark narrative of domestic violence and betrayal. As Christopher Zwirtz and Roberta Slagle sit in jail, the evidence against them mounts. A wooden bat. A taser. A body on the porch.

For now, the Anderson family waits—waits for the autopsy, waits for the upgraded charges, and waits for the day they can face the people accused of taking their “happy person” away from them.

Rest in Peace, Cheyann Paige Anderson.

---

Summary of Key Facts:

• Victim: Cheyann Paige Anderson, 23.

• Date of Death: January 29, 2026.

• Location: Whitehorn Cove, Wagoner County, OK.

• Suspects: Christopher Zwirtz & Roberta Slagle (Roommates).

• Charges: Currently Assault (Pending ME report for Homicide).

• Injuries: Severe beating (wooden bat) and multiple taser burns.

• Family: Mother to a 2-year-old daughter.

• Investigating Agency: Wagoner County Sheriff’s Office.